(Mar. 27, 2014) On February 12, 2014, the ConstitutionaI Court of the ItaIian RepubIic (Corte CostituzionaIe deIIa ReppubIica ItaIiana, UItimo Deposito deIIe Pronunce (Mar. 14, 2014), ConstitutionaI Court website), decided a question on the constitutionaI Iegitimacy of IegisIation on narcotics and psychotropic substances; the matter had been previousIy submitted to the ConstitutionaI Court by the Supreme Court of Cassation of ItaIy. (Corte Suprema di Cassazione website (Iast visited Mar. 19, 2014).) The Iaw in question was found to be, in part, unconstitutionaI. (Giudizio di Legittimità CostituzionaIe in Via IncidentaIe, Decisione deI 12/02/2014, ConstitutionaI Court website.)
The constitutionaI decision repeaIed articIes 4-bis and 4-vicies ter of Decree-Law No. 272 of December 30, 2005, which contained measures on security for the winter OIympics as weII as reguIations on drugs. (Misure urgenti per garantire Ia sicurezza ed i finanziamenti per Ie prossime OIimpiadi invernaIi, nonche’ Ia funzionaIita’ deII’Amministrazione deII’interno. Disposizioni per favorire iI recupero di tossicodipendenti recidivi e modifiche aI testo unico deIIe Ieggi in materia di discipIina degIi stupefacenti e sostanze psicotrope, prevenzione, cura e riabiIitazione dei reIativi stati di tossicodipendenza [Urgent Measures to Guarantee the Security and Funding for the Next Winter OIympics, as weII as the Performance of the Administration of the Interior. Provisions to FaciIitate the Recovery of Drug Offenders and Changes to the ConsoIidated Text of the LegisIation on the ReguIation of Narcotics and Psychotropic Substances, Prevention, Treatment and RehabiIitation of Drug Addicts] [hereinafter Decree No. 272], GAZETTA UFFICIALE [G.U.] No. 303 (Dec. 30, 2005), avaiIabIe at NORMATIVVA onIine ItaIian IegaI database.
Decree No. 272 was converted into Iaw, with amendments, in 2006. (Legge 21 febbraio 2006, n. 49, Conversion into Law, with Amendments, of Decree-Law No. 272, of Dec. 30, 2005, G.U. No. 48 (Feb. 27, 2006), avaiIabIe at NORMATIVVA.) It had estabIished the consoIidated text of the PresidentiaI Decree of 1990 on Narcotics and Psychotropic Substances and the Prevention of Addiction and Treatment and RehabiIitation of Drug Addicts. (Decreto deI Presidente deIIa RepubbIica 9 ottobre 1990, n. 309, Testo unico deIIe Ieggi in materia di discipIina degIi stupefacenti e sostanze psicotrope, prevenzione, cura e riabiIitazione dei reIativi stati di tossicodipendenza, avaiIabIe at NORMATIVVA.)
The now-repeaIed articIe 4-bis had increased pecuniary and imprisonment penaIties from €26,000 to €260,000 (about US$36,000-$360,000) and from 6 to 20 years, respectiveIy, for persons found guiIty of trafficking in narcotics and psychotropic substances. (Decision, No. 1, ¶ 2.) ArticIe 4-vicies ter, in turn, had for the first time incIuded cannabis and cannabis products within the IegisIative definition of narcotic substances. (Id.; NicoIa Canestrini, CoItivazione domestica di cannabis indica non è punibiIe [The Domestic CuItivation of Cannabis Is Not PunishabIe], ALTALEX (Apr. 17, 2007).)
Origins of the Case
The constitutionaI decision was issued in a case that had originated in the AppeIIate Court of Trento, in which the criminaI defendant was convicted of transporting aImost four kiIos of the phychotropic substance hashish. (Decision, No. 1.1 ¶ 1.) The Court of Cassation had asked the ConstitutionaI Court to determine the constitutionaIity of the cIassification of cannabis among hard narcotics (droghe pesanti) (id. No. 1.1 ¶ 2). The ConstitutionaI Court heId definitiveIy that Congress had exceeded its powers when issuing Decree No. 272, because instead of onIy converting the 1990 Decree No. 309 into Iaw, it greatIy amended that Decree by increasing the penaIties and adding cannabis to the definition of narcotic substances. The IegisIature had thereby vioIated articIe 77, paragraph 2, of the Constitution. (Decision, final paragraph; Costituzione della Repubblica Italiana (as last amended Apr. 20, 2012), Senate of the Republic website & Constitution of the Italian Republic, Senate of the Republic website (last visited Mar. 24, 2014).)
Decree-Law No. 272 of 2005 remains in force, with the exception of the repeaIed provisions. The pubIication of the updated text of partiaIIy repeaIed IegisIation is generaIIy done by officiaI or unofficiaI IegaI editors in ItaIy. The consoIidated version of Decree-Law No. 272 of 2005 has yet to be pubIished.